Micro-listening
Must, might, or can't: choose right modal
The short answer
Deduction modals show your confidence about a situation right now. They do not express permission or ability. Must means you are almost certain because the clues point to one clear answer. Might and could mean several explanations are possible. Can't means the clues show an idea is impossible.
Key points
- Check your evidence before you pick a modal verb.
- Use must when one answer feels almost certain.
- Use might or could when other explanations are possible.
This lesson has 5 stages. You can stop at any time and continue later.
Stage 1 of 5
Understand
What it means, when to use it, and mistakes to avoid.
Examples
The kitchen smells like garlic, so Marco must be cooking dinner.
Why it works: Must be cooking shows a confident conclusion based on the strong smell.
3 more examples
-
The parcel can't be from Elena because she texted that she forgot to send it.
Can't be shows that Elena's text makes her being the sender impossible.
-
Leo might need a ride home if the bus has stopped running.
Might need expresses one possible outcome without claiming certainty.
-
The front gate is unlocked, so our guests could be waiting in the garden.
Could be waiting offers an open possibility supported by the unlocked gate.
Read the full guide
Notice clues to make a deduction
When you make a deduction in English, you do not guess blindly. You look at physical clues, listen to sounds, or recall known facts, and then you decide what makes sense. The modal verb you select tells the listener how much evidence you have and how confident you feel about your conclusion.
-
His umbrella is dripping wet, so it must be pouring outside.
Why it works: The dripping umbrella provides visible proof for the conclusion about the weather.
-
The coffee shop is dark inside, so they might be closed for cleaning.
Why it works: The dark windows suggest one possible explanation among several.
Your turn
You find a set of car keys on the breakroom table next to David's notebook. Which sentence shows a reasonable deduction?
Answer: David must be in the office today.
Show the answer
Answer: David must be in the office today.
His personal notebook and car keys on the table provide strong evidence that he is in the office.
Use must when the clues point to one clear answer
Use must when your observations make one conclusion almost certain. You do not have absolute proof, but no other explanation seems likely. Keep in mind that must stays in the same form for every subject pronoun, and the verb that follows must always remain in its base form without to.
-
Maya has worked ten hours straight, so she must feel exhausted.
Why it works: Ten hours of continuous work strongly supports the conclusion that Maya is exhausted.
-
The delivery van is parked outside our gate, so that must be our package.
Why it works: The presence of the van makes that package the most logical explanation.
You can practise this again in Must, might, or can't: express certainty and doubt and Phrasal verbs with cry: choose the right phrase.
Your turn
The receptionist points at an empty chair and a warm cup of tea. What is the best deduction?
Answer: The manager must be nearby.
Show the answer
Answer: The manager must be nearby.
The warm tea left behind is a clear clue that the manager stepped away only for a moment.
Use can't when facts make an idea impossible
When visible clues or verified facts show that an explanation cannot happen, use can't followed by a base verb. Can't functions as the negative opposite of must in deduction. Do not substitute mustn't here, because mustn't tells someone not to do something rather than describing an impossibility.
-
That man can't be our doctor because our clinic is closed on Sundays.
Why it works: The clinic schedule makes the man's identity as their working doctor impossible.
-
You can't be hungry already after eating that large sandwich.
Why it works: The large meal eaten moments ago rules out real hunger.
Your turn
Your friend says Carlos is waiting outside, but Carlos is talking to you on a video call from another city. What should you say?
Answer: He can't be outside our door.
Show the answer
Answer: He can't be outside our door.
The active video call from another city proves Carlos cannot be standing outside your door.
Use might or could when several answers are possible
Sometimes the available clues allow for more than one sensible answer. When you want to suggest an explanation without sounding completely sure, use might or could followed by a base verb. Both words show that your statement is a guess, and neither word rules out other realistic possibilities.
-
The hallway light is blinking, so the bulb might be loose.
Why it works: A loose bulb is one possible reason, but faulty wiring is another.
-
Hannah could have the spare office key in her desk drawer.
Why it works: Could presents Hannah's desk as a possible location without ruling out other spots.
Your turn
You hear a knock at the door, but you are not expecting any visitors. How do you express an open possibility?
Answer: It could be the postal carrier with a catalog.
Show the answer
Answer: It could be the postal carrier with a catalog.
Could expresses an open, realistic guess when you do not know who is knocking.
Choose be to describe states, identities, and locations
Many deductions describe where someone is, who someone is, or how someone feels. In these situations, place the base form be immediately after the modal verb. Never replace be with conjugated forms such as is, are, or am, and avoid adding to between the modal verb and be.
-
The engine is completely cold, so the car must be broken.
Why it works: Broken is a state, so be follows must directly.
-
The noise sounds like barking, so that animal might be a dog.
Why it works: Be connects the modal to the noun phrase describing identity.
Your turn
Which sentence correctly describes a person's location based on visible clues?
Answer: Tariq must be in the library.
Show the answer
Answer: Tariq must be in the library.
Follow the modal must with the base verb be, without using is or adding to.
Describe actions happening right now with be and ing
When you make a deduction about an action happening at this exact moment, use modal plus be plus an ing verb. This pattern combines your certainty level with continuous aspect. It allows you to describe ongoing work, movement, or background activity without claiming that you witnessed the action start.
-
We hear loud drills upstairs, so the workers must be repairing the pipes.
Why it works: Must be repairing describes an ongoing action deduced from current sounds.
-
Sonja is not answering her mobile phone, but she might be driving home.
Why it works: Might be driving suggests a possible continuous action in progress.
Your turn
You see smoke rising from your neighbor's barbecue grill. What is happening now?
Answer: They must be cooking dinner.
Show the answer
Answer: They must be cooking dinner.
Use must be cooking to show a strong deduction about an action happening right now.
Avoid common deduction mistakes with can and mustn't
Learners often make two common mistakes with deduction modals. First, do not use can for positive deductions; use could or might instead. Can expresses general ability, not deduction about a specific situation. Second, never use mustn't to mean impossible; use can't whenever the evidence contradicts your idea.
-
The meeting could run late because the agenda has eight points.
Why it works: Use could rather than can for a specific present deduction.
-
That price can't be correct for a simple cup of tea.
Why it works: Use can't rather than mustn't to say a price is impossible.
Your turn
Choose the correct sentence to express that an online story is impossible:
Answer: That headline can't be true.
Show the answer
Answer: That headline can't be true.
Use can't be to reject an impossible claim. Mustn't expresses an order or rule.
Respond naturally to deductions in conversation
In daily conversations, speakers frequently test deductions together. When a colleague suggests a possibility using might, you can support it with extra clues using must, or dismiss it with can't. Short responses such as He might be or It can't be keep your conversation fast and natural.
-
She might be at lunch, but her computer screen is still unlocked.
Why it works: The speaker contrasts a tentative guess with a physical clue.
-
It can't be four o'clock yet because the school bell has not rung.
Why it works: The absence of the school bell provides evidence against the time.
Your turn
Your coworker asks if the printer is out of paper. You see fifty fresh sheets in the tray. How do you respond?
Answer: It can't be out of paper; the tray is full.
Show the answer
Answer: It can't be out of paper; the tray is full.
The visible full paper tray makes running out of paper impossible.
Questions about "Must, might, or can't: choose right modal"
Can I use 'can' instead of 'could' for positive deductions?
No. In standard English deduction, we avoid using can to make positive guesses about a specific situation. Can expresses general possibility or ability, such as 'Winters can be cold in Chicago.' When you deduce something about a specific moment, use could or might instead.
She could be waiting by the elevator right now.
The key might be on your kitchen counter.
Why do we say 'it can't be' instead of 'it mustn't be'?
Mustn't expresses an obligation or prohibition, meaning someone is not allowed to do something. When you reject a conclusion because the evidence shows it is impossible, use can't. Saying 'It can't be true' means the evidence proves the statement false.
You mustn't park here; this space is reserved.
That car can't belong to Sarah because hers is blue.
Is there a real difference between 'might' and 'could' in deductions?
In everyday present deductions, might and could express almost identical levels of uncertainty. Both show that the speaker considers an explanation possible without claiming certainty. Could sometimes highlights available options, while might emphasizes doubt, but native speakers use them interchangeably.
We might catch the earlier train if we run.
We could catch the earlier train if the platform is clear.
When should I add 'be' and an '-ing' verb after a deduction modal?
Use modal plus be plus an ing verb when your deduction concerns an activity taking place right now. If your deduction describes an ongoing action rather than a permanent state or routine fact, the continuous form makes that timing clear to your listener.
Dan must be sleeping because his phone goes straight to voicemail.
They might be driving through the tunnel where there is no cellular signal.
Before you go
Remember this
Check your evidence before you pick a modal verb. Use must when one answer feels almost certain. Use might or could when other explanations are possible. Use can't when the facts rule an idea out. Always follow the modal with the base form of the verb.
Stage 2 of 5
Listen
Hear it in real sentences, from short to long, and write what you hear.
0 of 4 done
Listening 1 of 4
Listening 2 of 4
Try a longer clip. Listen once, then replay the part you missed.
Listening 3 of 4
This clip is longer. Follow the instruction above the answer field.
Listening 4 of 4
Listen, then type the missing words. The rest of the text is already there.
0:00
Practice complete
You listened closely.
Your result is saved in this browser.
Keep your progress. Your practice is saved on this device only. Create a free account to keep it everywhere.
Create a free accountThat was today's free lesson. Tomorrow you get another one. Want more today? See membership.
Create a free SubLearn account to keep this progress across devices.
Save my progressStage 3 of 5
Speak
Say it with the speaker, then use it in your own answer.
Shadow
Say it along with the speaker
Play the line slowly, then speak at the same time as the speaker. Copy the rhythm, not just the words.
Your turn
Say it your way
Describe an unexpected scene in your office breakroom where you see dirty cups and open cake boxes. Explain what must, might, or can't be happening.
You could start with “Looking at the open cake boxes on the table, the team must be…”
Take ten seconds to think, then answer out loud without looking at the lesson. Speak for the time shown in the task above. Nothing is sent unless you ask for feedback.
0:00
Stage 4 of 5
Write
Write your own response
AI feedback · it can make mistakes · Part of membership See membership
Check your own writing
Read one possible response
Draft saved on this device.
Use these checks to revise your message. Grammar and meaning are not automatically graded. Each task keeps its own draft in this browser tab.
You finished the free part of this lesson
- Understand
- Listen
- Speak
- Write
- CheckPart of membership
Worth another look
With a free account, the lessons you finish come back for review to help you remember them.Create a free account
Stage 5 of 5 · Part of membership
Check
New clips without hints.
Listening tests are included with membership. Try the free dictation first, then decide whether to continue.
Listening 1 of 2 Part of membership
Listening 2 of 2 Part of membership
Follow MicroEnglish
Find lesson updates, short videos and quick quizzes. Pick the app you already use.
Questions & comments
Ask about this lesson, share an example, or help another learner.
Example
Memory tip
Goes with
Related forms
Not to be confused with
In this lesson
This word isn't in our dictionary. Check the spelling, or try another form of the word.
We couldn't load this word. Try again.
